In China, a recent spate of arrests
of Internet users is raising concerns that authorities may be targeting average
people and accusing them of subversion. The trend marks a departure from the
past, when police crackdowns focused on prominent dissidents.
Before her arrest more than a year ago, Liu Di was a university psychology
student virtually unknown to all but a few Internet users who read her postings,
in which she talked about everything from the human psyche to contemporary
Now, the young woman has been jailed as a dissident for more than a year
and has become the center of international attention as human rights activists
push for her release. No charges have been filed against her.
Before her arrest, 23-year-old Liu Di lived with her grandmother, Liu Heng.
Mrs. Liu is a retired journalist who herself was thrown in prison in 1957 after
the government of Communist leader Mao Zedong labeled her an "incorrigible
rightist." Speaking briefly before her telephone went dead, she said her granddaughter
does not fit the mold of a radical student activist. "I'm still not sure about
the whole situation. However, I think she made some mistakes," says Mrs. Liu. " What
mistakes she made, I'm still not sure about. The government was suspicious
and arrested her.
Using the alias of Stainless Steel Mouse, Ms. Liu posted essays on-line expressing
sympathy for jailed Internet activists and criticizing a government decision
last year to close thousands of Internet cafes.
Peng Dingding, an Internet activist who has taken up her cause, says Ms.
Liu's postings challenged the communist system but were not enough to make
her a prominent dissident. He describes one of her on-line comments. "She said,
let's make an experiment. She said let's take the communist manifesto and take
off the cover, and read it to the people, and see whether they agree with the
manifesto," he said. Mr. Peng said what he finds most disturbing about Ms.
Liu's case that authorities have yet to say why she is being detained.
Liu Di's detention has raised fear that anyone could be arrested, especially
at a time when rising unemployment and other social problems are driving many
young people to vent their concerns on the Internet.
The global human rights advocacy group Amnesty International says at least
40 people are currently jailed in China for Internet-related offenses. The
number is small when compared with the 68 million Internet users in the country.
Some legal experts say the small number of arrests could reflect the difficulty
that authorities have in controlling something as large as the Internet.
The government has formed an Internet police force that is estimated to employ
thousands of people to monitor cyberspace activity. However, observers say
the job of tracking millions of Internet users is too large for any police
force, regardless of how well staffed.
Authorities are apparently having trouble getting charges against Ms. Liu
to stick. Family members last month said prosecutors bounced the case back
to police, demanding that investigators come up with better evidence.
Still, Ms. Liu remains in prison.
Chinese law says criminal suspects may be held without charges for up to
two months, with extensions possible in cases that are deemed severe. With
few leads to go on and no large kingpins to target, the government is using
those it detains as threads to go after others it knows are posting politically
On October 28, plainclothes police raided the home of Du Daobin, a 40-year-old
office worker in Hubei province who posted essays criticizing government corruption.
Relatives say agents arrested Mr. Du after he had signed an on-line petition
demanding the release of Liu Di.
"I don't know why they arrested my husband," said Huang Chunrong, who has
been visiting jails, searching for her husband. "I feel he just wrote a few
articles. He didn't do anything else. I don't think he did anything radical
like they say he did. I don't understand what is being called 'radical.' He
just wrote some articles. '
Michael Davis teaches law at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. He sees
the random arrests as an indication that Chinese Internet patrols are not finding
their work easy. "We have seen there's a sort of crackdown that is sporadic
at best because I think they realize the difficulties of controlling the Internet," he
Professor Davis says the authorities' approach seems to be along the lines
of an old Chinese proverb that says, "kill the chicken to scare the monkey." "One
of the techniques we've seen recently is one of arresting someone prominently
and visibly so that it becomes a warning to others to back off in whatever
they may be doing on the Internet."
A reporter attempted several times to interview officials with China's Public
Security Bureau in Beijing. Officials did not return calls. The case of Liu
Di has triggered worldwide protests by human rights advocates to demand that
China release those it is holding for Internet-related offenses.
Five hundred intellectuals recently submitted a petition to Prime Minister
Wen Jiabao, urging him to intervene for the release of Du Daobin. The petition
warned that governments that perpetrate what the intellectuals termed "terrorist
rule" would lose their legitimacy.